Entanglement Certification $-$ From Theory to Experiment

Sebastian Ecker, Frédéric Bouchard, Lukas Bulla, Florian Brandt, Oskar Kohout, Fabian Steinlechner, Robert Fickler, Mehul Malik, Yelena Guryanova, Rupert Ursin, and Marcus Huber, “Entanglement distribution beyond qubits or: How I stopped worrying and learned to love the noise,” (2019), arXiv:1904.01552

Original

1904

Earlier work this paper cites.

Colin D. Bruzewicz, John Chiaverini, Robert McConnell, and Jeremy M. Sage, “Trapped-ion quantum computing: Progress and challenges,” Appl. Phys. Rev. 6

Original

1904

Earlier work this paper cites.

You Zhou, Qi Zhao, Xiao Yuan, and Xiongfeng Ma, “Efficient detection of multipartite entanglement structure,” (2019), arXiv:1904.05001

Original

1904

Earlier work this paper cites.

Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky, and Nathan Rosen, “Can quantum-mechanical description of physical reality be considered complete?” Phys. Rev. 47

1935

Earlier work this paper cites.

John Stewart Bell, “On the Einstein Podolsky Rosen Paradox,” Physics 1

1964

Earlier work this paper cites.

N. Behbood, F. Martin Ciurana, G. Colangelo, M. Napolitano, Géza Tóth, R. J. Sewell, and M. W. Mitchell, “Generation of Macroscopic Singlet States in a Cold Atomic Ensemble,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 113

Original

1964

Earlier work this paper cites.

J. F. Clauser, M. A. Horne, A. Shimony, and R. A. Holt, “Proposed Experiment to Test Local Hidden-Variable Theories,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 23

1969

Earlier work this paper cites.

Stuart J. Freedman and John F. Clauser, “Experimental Test of Local Hidden-Variable Theories,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 28

1972

Earlier work this paper cites.

M. Reed and B. Simon, Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics I: Functional Analysis (Academic Press, New York and London, 1972)

1972

Earlier work this paper cites.

Alain Aspect, Philippe Grangier, and Gérard Roger, “Experimental Tests of Realistic Local Theories via Bell’s Theorem,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 47

1981

Earlier work this paper cites.

Charles H. Bennett and Gilles Brassard, “Quantum cryptography: public key distribution and coin tossing,” in Proc. IEEE International Conference on Computers, Systems and Signal Processing (1984) pp. 175–179

1984

Earlier work this paper cites.

Charles H. Bennett and Gilles Brassard, “Quantum cryptography: Public key distribution and coin tossing,” Theor. Comput. Sci. 560

1984

Earlier work this paper cites.

Reinhard F. Werner, “Quantum states with Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlations admitting a hidden-variable model,” Phys. Rev. A 40

1989

Earlier work this paper cites.

M. D. Reid, “Demonstration of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox using nondegenerate parametric amplification,” Phys. Rev. A 40

1989

Earlier work this paper cites.

William K. Wootters and Brian D. Fields, “Optimal state-determination by mutually unbiased measurements,” Ann. Phys. 191

1989

Earlier work this paper cites.

Johan Håstad, “Tensor rank is NP-complete,” J. Algorithm 11

1990

Earlier work this paper cites.

A. K. Ekert, “Quantum cryptography based on Bell’s theorem,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 67

1991

Earlier work this paper cites.

D. J. Wineland, J. J. Bollinger, W. M. Itano, F. L. Moore, and D. J. Heinzen, “Spin squeezing and reduced quantum noise in spectroscopy,” Phys. Rev. A 46

1992

Earlier work this paper cites.

L. Allen, M. Beijersbergen, R. J. C. Spreeuw, and J. P. Woerdman, “Orbital angular momentum of light and the transformation of Laguerre-Gaussian laser modes,” Phys. Rev. A 45

1992

Earlier work this paper cites.

C. H. Bennett, G. Brassard, C. Crépeau, R. Jozsa, A. Peres, and W. K. Wootters, “Teleporting an Unknown Quantum State via Dual Classical and Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Channels,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 70

1993

Earlier work this paper cites.

Masahiro Kitagawa and Masahito Ueda, “Squeezed spin states,” Phys. Rev. A 47

1993

Earlier work this paper cites.

S. L. Braunstein and C. M. Caves, “Statistical distance and the geometry of quantum states,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 72

1994

Earlier work this paper cites.

D. J. Wineland, J. J. Bollinger, W. M. Itano, and D. J. Heinzen, “Squeezed atomic states and projection noise in spectroscopy,” Phys. Rev. A 50

1994

Earlier work this paper cites.

Marek Żukowski, Anton Zeilinger, and Harald Weinfurter, “Entangling Photons Radiated by Independent Pulsed Sources,” Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 755

1995

Earlier work this paper cites.

Seth Lloyd, “Universal quantum simulators,” Science 273

1996

Earlier work this paper cites.

Asher Peres, “Separability Criterion for Density Matrices,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 77

1996

Earlier work this paper cites.

Michał Horodecki, Paweł Horodecki, and Ryszard Horodecki, “Separability of mixed states: necessary and sufficient conditions,” Phys. Lett. A 223

1996

Earlier work this paper cites.

D. Bouwmeester, Jian-Wei Pan, K. Mattle, M. Eibl, H. Weinfurter, and Anton Zeilinger, “Experimental Quantum Teleportation,” Nature 390

1997

Earlier work this paper cites.

S. F. Huelga, Chiara Macchiavello, T. Pellizzari, A. K. Ekert, Martin B. Plenio, and Juan Ignacio Cirac, “On the Improvement of Frequency Stardards with Quantum Entanglement,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 79

1997

Earlier work this paper cites.

A. Kuzmich, Klaus Mølmer, and E. S. Polzik, “Spin Squeezing in an Ensemble of Atoms Illuminated with Squeezed Light,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 79

1997

Earlier work this paper cites.

Gregor Weihs, Thomas Jennewein, Christoph Simon, Harald Weinfurter, and Anton Zeilinger, “Violation of Bell’s Inequality under Strict Einstein Locality Conditions,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 81

1998

Earlier work this paper cites.

William K. Wootters, “Entanglement of Formation of an Arbitrary State of Two Qubits,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 80

1998

Earlier work this paper cites.

Michał Horodecki, Paweł Horodecki, and Ryszard Horodecki, “Mixed-State Entanglement and Distillation: Is there a “Bound” Entanglement in Nature?” Phys. Rev. Lett. 80

1998

Earlier work this paper cites.

Michael A. Nielsen, “Conditions for a Class of Entanglement Transformations,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 83

1999

Earlier work this paper cites.

Juan Maldacena, “The Large-N Limit of Superconformal Field Theories and Supergravity,” Int. J. Theor. Phys. 38

1999

Earlier work this paper cites.

Dik Bouwmeester, Jian-Wei Pan, Matthew Daniell, Harald Weinfurter, and Anton Zeilinger, “Observation of Three-Photon Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger Entanglement,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 82

1999

Earlier work this paper cites.

J. Hald, J. L. Sørensen, C. Schori, and E. S. Polzik, “Spin Squeezed Atoms: A Macroscopic Entangled Ensemble Created by Light,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 83

1999

Earlier work this paper cites.

M. A. Nielsen and I. L. Chuang, Quantum Computation and Quantum Information (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K., 2000)

2000

Earlier work this paper cites.

Barbara M. Terhal and Paveł Horodecki, “Schmidt number for density matrices,” Phys. Rev. A 61

2000

Earlier work this paper cites.

Guifré Vidal, “Entanglement monotones,” J. Mod. Opt. 47

2000

Earlier work this paper cites.

Barbara M. Terhal, “Bell inequalities and the separability criterion,” Phys. Lett. A 271

2000

Earlier work this paper cites.

Jian-Wei Pan, Dik Bouwmeester, Matthew Daniell, Harald Weinfurter, and Anton Zeilinger, “Experimental test of quantum nonlocality in three-photon Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger entanglement,” Nature 403

2000

Earlier work this paper cites.

Wolfgang Dür, Guifré Vidal, and Juan Ignacio Cirac, “Three qubits can be entangled in two inequivalent ways,” Phys. Rev. A 62

2000

Earlier work this paper cites.

Valerie Coffman, Joydip Kundu, and William K. Wootters, “Distributed entanglement,” Phys. Rev. A 61

2000

Earlier work this paper cites.

A. Kuzmich, L. Mandel, and N. P. Bigelow, “Generation of Spin Squeezing via Continuous Quantum Nondemolition Measurement,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 85

2000

Earlier work this paper cites.

Michael A. Nielsen and Guifré Vidal, “Majorization and the interconversion of bipartite states,” Quant. Inf. Comput. 1

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Patrick M. Hayden, Michał Horodecki, and Barbara M. Terhal, “The asymptotic entanglement cost of preparing a quantum state,” J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 34

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

J. Eisert, Entanglement in quantum information theory , Ph.D. thesis, University of Potsdam (2001), arXiv:quant-ph/0610253

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Oliver Rudolph, “A new class of entanglement measures,” J. Math. Phys. 42

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Anders Sørensen and Klaus Mølmer, “Entanglement and Extreme Spin Squeezing,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 86

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Zhi-Hao Ma, Zhi-Hua Chen, Jing-Ling Chen, Christoph Spengler, Andreas Gabriel, and Marcus Huber, “Measure of genuine multipartite entanglement with computable lower bounds,” Phys. Rev. A 83

Original

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Anna Sanpera, Dagmar Bruß, and Maciej Lewenstein, “Schmidt-number witnesses and bound entanglement,” Phys. Rev. A 63

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Robert Raussendorf and Hans J. Briegel, “A One-Way Quantum Computer,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 86

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Hans J. Briegel and Robert Raussendorf, “Persistent Entanglement in Arrays of Interacting Particles,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 86

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Jian-Wei Pan, Matthew Daniell, Sara Gasparoni, Gregor Weihs, and Anton Zeilinger, “Experimental Demonstration of Four-Photon Entanglement and High-Fidelity Teleportation,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 86

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Antonio Acín, Dagmar Bruß, Maciej Lewenstein, and Anna Sanpera, “Classification of Mixed Three-Qubit States,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 87

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Anders Sørensen, Lu-Ming Duan, Juan Ignacio Cirac, and Peter Zoller, “Many-particle entanglement with Bose-Einstein condensates,” Nature 409

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

C. Orzel, A. K. Tuchman, M. L. Fenselau, M. Yasuda, and M. A. Kasevich, “Squeezed States in a Bose-Einstein Condensate,” Science 291

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

Brian Julsgaard, Alexander Kozhekin, and Eugene S. Polzik, “Experimental long-lived entanglement of two macroscopic objects,” Nature 413

2001

Earlier work this paper cites.

J. Barrett, “Nonsequential positive-operator-valued measurements on entangled mixed states do not always violate a Bell inequality,” Phys. Rev. A 65

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

Dagmar Bruß, “Characterizing Entanglement,” J. Math. Phys. 43

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

N. J. Cerf, M. Bourennane, A. Karlsson, and N. Gisin, “Security of Quantum Key Distribution Using d \mathit{d} -Level Systems,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 88

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

G. Vidal and R. F. Werner, “Computable measure of entanglement,” Phys. Rev. A 65

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

R. A. Bertlmann, H. Narnhofer, and W. Thirring, “A Geometric Picture of Entanglement and Bell Inequalities,” Phys. Rev. A 66

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

D. Collins, N. Gisin, N. Linden, S. Massar, and S. Popescu, “Bell Inequalities for Arbitrarily High-Dimensional Systems,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 88

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

Alipasha Vaziri, Gregor Weihs, and Anton Zeilinger, “Experimental Two-Photon, Three-Dimensional Entanglement for Quantum Communication,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 89

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

H. de Riedmatten, I. Marcikic, H. Zbinden, and Nicolas Gisin, “Creating high dimensional time-bin entanglement using mode-locked lasers,” Quantum Inf. Comput. 2

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

Jonathan Leach, Miles J. Padgett, Stephen M. Barnett, Sonja Franke-Arnold, and Johannes Courtial, “Measuring the Orbital Angular Momentum of a Single Photon,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 88

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

F. Verstraete, J. Dehaene, B. De Moor, and H. Verschelde, “Four qubits can be entangled in nine different ways,” Phys. Rev. A 65

2002

Earlier work this paper cites.

Richard Jozsa and Noah Linden, “On the Role of Entanglement in Quantum-Computational Speed-Up,” Proc. Roy. Soc. A Math. Phys. 459

2003

Earlier work this paper cites.

Leonid Gurvits, “Classical Deterministic Complexity of Edmonds’ Problem and Quantum Entanglement,” in Proceedings of the Thirty-fifth Annual ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing , STOC ’03 (ACM, New York, NY, USA, 2003) pp. 10–19, arXiv:quant-ph/0303055

2003

Earlier work this paper cites.

Leonid Gurvits, “Classical complexity and quantum entanglement,” J. Comput. Syst. Sci. 69

2003

Earlier work this paper cites.

Oliver Rudolph, “Some properties of the computable cross norm criterion for separability,” Phys. Rev. A 67

2003

Earlier work this paper cites.

Kai Chen and Ling-An Wu, “A matrix realignment method for recognizing entanglement,” Quant. Inf. Comput. 3

2003

Earlier work this paper cites.

Holger F. Hofmann and Shigeki Takeuchi, “Violation of local uncertainty relations as a signature of entanglement,” Phys. Rev. A 68

2003

Earlier work this paper cites.

Frank Verstraete, Jeroen Dehaene, and Bart De Moor, “Normal forms and entanglement measures for multipartite quantum states,” Phys. Rev. A 68

2003

Earlier work this paper cites.

A. Poppe, A. Fedrizzi, T. Loruenser, O. Maurhardt, R. Ursin, H. R. Böhm, M. Peev, M. Suda, C. Kurtsiefer, H. Weinfurter, T. Jennewein, and Anton Zeilinger, “Practical Quantum Key Distribution with Polarization-Entangled Photons,” Opt. Express 12

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

Joseph B. Altepeter, Daniel F. V. James, and Paul G. Kwiat, “4 Qubit Quantum State Tomography,” in Quantum State Estimation , edited by Matteo Paris and Jaroslav Řeháček (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2004) pp. 113–145

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

John Watrous, “Many Copies May Be Required for Entanglement Distillation,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 93

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

Mark R. Dowling, Andrew C. Doherty, and Stephen D. Bartlett, “Energy as an entanglement witness for quantum many-body systems,” Phys. Rev. A 70

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

C. K. Law and J. H. Eberly, “Analysis and Interpretation of High Transverse Entanglement in Optical Parametric Down Conversion,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 92

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

R. T. Thew, A. Acín, H. Zbinden, and N. Gisin, “Bell-Type Test of Energy-Time Entangled Qutrits,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 93

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

A. J. Scott, “Multipartite entanglement, quantum-error-correcting codes, and entangling power of quantum evolutions,” Phys. Rev. A 69

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

M. Hein, Jens Eisert, and Hans J. Briegel, “Multiparty entanglement in graph states,” Phys. Rev. A 69

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

Matthias Christandl and Andreas Winter, ““squashed entanglement”: An additive entanglement measure,” J. Math. Phys. 45

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

Mohamed Bourennane, Manfred Eibl, Christian Kurtsiefer, Sascha Gaertner, Harald Weinfurter, Otfried Gühne, Philipp Hyllus, Dagmar Bruß, Maciej Lewenstein, and Anna Sanpera, “Experimental Detection of Multipartite Entanglement using Witness Operators,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 92

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

Brian Julsgaard, Jacob Sherson, Juan Ignacio Cirac, Jaromir Fiurasek, and Eugene S. Polzik, “Experimental demonstration of quantum memory for light,” Nature 432

2004

Earlier work this paper cites.

Samuel L. Braunstein and Peter van Loock, “Quantum information with continuous variables,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 77

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Alessandro Ferraro, Stefano Olivares, and Matteo G. A. Paris, Gaussian States in Quantum Information , Napoli Series on Physics and Astrophysics (Bibliopolis, 2005) arXiv:quant-ph/0503237

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Martin B. Plenio, “Logarithmic Negativity: A Full Entanglement Monotone That is not Convex,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 95

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Oliver Rudolph, “Further results on the cross norm criterion for separability,” Quantum Inf. Process. 4

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Géza Tóth, “Entanglement witnesses in spin models,” Phys. Rev. A 71

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Gilad Gour, “Family of concurrence monotones and its applications,” Phys. Rev. A 71

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Malcolm O’Sullivan, Irfan Ali Khan, Robert W. Boyd, and John Howell, “Pixel Entanglement: Experimental Realization of Optically Entangled d= 3 and d= 6 Qudits,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 94

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Julio Barreiro, Nathan Langford, Nicholas Peters, and Paul Kwiat, “Generation of Hyperentangled Photon Pairs,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 95

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Koenraad M. R. Audenaert and Martin B. Plenio, “Entanglement on mixed stabilizer states: normal forms and reduction procedures,” New J. Phys. 7

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Otfried Gühne, Géza Tóth, and Hans J. Briegel, “Multipartite entanglement in spin chains,” New J. Phys. 7

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

Andreas Osterloh and Jens Siewert, “Constructing n n -qubit entanglement monotones from antilinear operators,” Phys. Rev. A 72

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

D. Leibfried, E. Knill, S. Seidelin, J. Britton, R. B. Blakestad, J. Chiaverini, D. B. Hume, W. M. Itano, J. D. Jost, C. Langer, R. Ozeri, R. Reichle, and D. J. Wineland, “Creation of a six-atom ‘Schrödinger cat’ state,” Nature 438

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

H. Häffner, W. Hänsel, C. F. Roos, J. Benhelm, D. Chek-al kar, M. Chwalla, T. Körber, U. D. Rapol, M. Riebe, P. O. Schmidt, C. Becher, O. Gühne, W. Dür, and R. Blatt, “Scalable multiparticle entanglement of trapped ions,” Nature 438

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

M. Hein, W. Dür, Jens Eisert, Robert Raussendorf, M. Van den Nest, and Hans. J. Briegel, “Entanglement in graph states and its applications,” Proceedings of the International School of Physics ”Enrico Fermi” 162

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

M. Wieśniak, Vlatko Vedral, and Časlav Brukner, “Magnetic susceptibility as a macroscopic entanglement witness,” New J. Phys. 7

2005

Earlier work this paper cites.

A. Acín, N. Gisin, and B. Toner, “Grothendieck’s constant and local models for noisy entangled quantum states,” Phys. Rev. A 73

2006

Earlier work this paper cites.

J. Barrett, A. Kent, and S. Pironio, “Maximally Nonlocal and Monogamous Quantum Correlations,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 97

2006

Earlier work this paper cites.

S. Gröblacher, T. Jennewein, Alipasha Vaziri, Gregor Weihs, and Anton Zeilinger, “Experimental quantum cryptography with qutrits,” New J. Phys. 8

2006

Earlier work this paper cites.

Vittorio Giovannetti, Seth Lloyd, and Lorenzo Maccone, “Quantum Metrology,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 96

2006

Earlier work this paper cites.

M. Ansmann, Radoslaw C. Bialczak, N. Katz, Erik Lucero, R. McDermott, Matthew Neeley, E. M. Weig, A. N. Cleland, and John M. Martinis, “Measurement of the entanglement of two superconducting qubits via state tomography,” Science 313

2006

Earlier work this paper cites.

Michał Horodecki, Paweł Horodecki, and Ryszard Horodecki, “Separability of Mixed Quantum States: Linear Contractions and Permutation Criteria,” Open Syst. Inf. Dyn. 13

2006

Earlier work this paper cites.

Otfried Gühne, Matyas Mechler, Géza Tóth, and Peter Adam, “Entanglement criteria based on local uncertainty relations are strictly stronger than the computable cross norm criterion,” Phys. Rev. A 74

2006

Earlier work this paper cites.

Graeme Smith and Debbie Leung, “Typical entanglement of stabilizer states,” Phys. Rev. A 74

2006

Cited alongside, same era.

Tobias J. Osborne and Frank Verstraete, “General Monogamy Inequality for Bipartite Qubit Entanglement,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 96

2006

Cited alongside, same era.

Časlav Brukner, Vlatko Vedral, and Anton Zeilinger, “Crucial role of quantum entanglement in bulk properties of solids,” Phys. Rev. A 73

2006

Cited alongside, same era.

R. Ursin, F. Tiefenbacher, T. Schmitt-Manderbach, H. Weier, T. Scheidl, M. Lindenthal, B. Blauensteiner, T. Jennewein, J. Perdigues, P. Trojek, B. Oemer, M. Fuerst, M. Meyenburg, J. Rarity, Z. Sodnik, C. Barbieri, H. Weinfurter, and Anton Zeilinger, “Entanglement-based quantum communication over 144 km,” Nat. Phys. 3

2007

Cited alongside, same era.

Martin B. Plenio and S. Virmani, “An introduction to entanglement measures,” Quant. Inf. Comput. 7

Giuseppe Vitagliano, Iagoba Apellaniz, Inigo L. Egusquiza, and Géza Tóth, “Spin squeezing and entanglement for an arbitrary spin,” Phys. Rev. A 89

Original

2014

Later among the works it cites.

J. Tura, R. Augusiak, A. B. Sainz, T. Vértesi, M. Lewenstein, and A. Acín, “Detecting nonlocality in many-body quantum states,” Science 344

Original

2014

Later among the works it cites.

Bernd Lücke, Jan Peise, Giuseppe Vitagliano, Jan Arlt, Luis Santos, Géza Tóth, and Carsten Klempt, “Detecting Multiparticle Entanglement of Dicke States,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 112

Original

2014

Later among the works it cites.

Oliver Marty, Michael Epping, Hermann Kampermann, Dagmar Bruß, Martin B. Plenio, and M. Cramer, “Quantifying entanglement with scattering experiments,” Phys. Rev. B 89

Original

2014

Later among the works it cites.