Lessons from a Chimp: AI "Scheming" and the Quest for Ape Language

Understand

We examine recent research that asks whether current AI systems may be developing a capacity for "scheming" (covertly and strategically pursuing misaligned goals).

• We compare current research practices in this field to those adopted in the 1970s to test whether non-human primates could master natural language.
• We argue that there are lessons to be learned from that historical research endeavour, which was characterised by an overattribution of human traits to other agents, an excessive reliance on anecdote and descriptive analysis, and a failure to articulate a strong theoretical framework for the research.
• We recommend that research into AI scheming actively seeks to avoid these pitfalls.